Florida Keys Restaurants
The Top 30 Florida Keys Restaurants for Guests Attending a Dream Bay Resort Wedding
The Florida Keys, with its picturesque views, warm ocean breezes, and unparalleled charm, is a paradise for couples, travel enthusiasts, and food lovers alike. Whether you're engaged and planning a destination wedding, attending as a wedding guest, or simply on the hunt for your next favorite dining spot, the Florida Keys boasts some of the most unique and unforgettable culinary experiences. From fine dining establishments to cozy local gems, here's our guide to the top 20 Florida Keys restaurants that should be on your must-visit list.
At Dream Bay Resort, we have a range of packages to make your wedding or special event unforgettable! Whether you’re planning a cozy elopement or microwedding (up to 50 guests) or a bigger celebration with up to 200 loved ones, we’re here to make your dreams a reality. Our 3-acre waterfront venue on the Gulf of Mexico is one of the most stunning spots in the Florida Keys, with breathtaking open water views and sunsets you’ll never forget!
Before we begin, we hope to share a little information about what makes Dream Bay Resort the perfect choice for your wedding and elopement. If you’re searching for the ideal Key Largo resort experience and Dream Bay seems like the perfect fit, we’d be delighted to assist you. Feel free to contact us to arrange a virtual or in-person tour. Explore our wedding packages, cozy cottages, and availability calendar for all the details you need to begin planning your wedding or elopement. We look forward to welcoming you and your wedding guests.
From stunning sunsets over crystal-clear waters to exclusive packages designed to elevate your weekend, here are 20 reasons why Dream Bay Resort is the ultimate choice for your destination wedding.
10 Fine Dining Restaurants in the Florida Keys
For a romantic evening or a special occasion, these fine dining spots in the Florida Keys are bound to impress with their ambiance, service, and cuisine.
1. Louie’s Backyard (Key West)
Set against a stunning ocean backdrop, this iconic Key West restaurant offers upscale Caribbean-American dishes with stellar service and a romantic setting. 700 Waddell Ave, Key West, FL 33040
Accessible by ferry, Latitudes delivers an unmatched luxury dining experience with the most gorgeous sunset views and fresh, locally inspired cuisine. 245 Front St, Key West, FL 33040
3. Pierre’s Restaurant (Islamorada)
This elegant, Moroccan-inspired gem offers gourmet dishes with French and tropical influences right on the waterfront. 81600 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
4. Hawks Cay Resort’s Angler & Ale (Duck Key)
An upscale seafood spot perfect for indulging in Key lime-marinated fish, complete with scenic harbor views. 540 Duck Key Dr, Duck Key, FL 33050
This boutique island restaurant offers an intimate ambiance with exquisite fine dining inspired by Mediterranean and Floridian flavors. 2600 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050
Known for its exquisite presentation and contemporary American cuisine, Azul offers an elevated dining experience that's perfect for couples. 425 Grinnell St, Key West, FL 33040
7. Little Palm Island Resort & Spa (Little Torch Key)
This ultra-private resort restaurant boasts a decadent menu and an experience like no other for those seeking luxury. 28500 Overseas Hwy, Little Torch Key, FL 33042
8. Trey’s (Big Pine Key)
An unforgettable island-style steak and seafood fine dining destination. Sophisticated yet welcoming.
Celebrated for its refined twists on classic seafood, The Stoned Crab offers incredible seafood towers and chargrilled fish platters. 3101 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, FL 33040
This table-cloth fine dining establishment serves a mix of local seafood and gourmet classics in a lush island setting. 2600 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050
Jannette De Llanos Photography
10 Florida Keys Restaurants Famous for a Special Menu Item
Blue Heaven (Key West) – Known for their towering, fluffy Key Lime Pie.729 Thomas St, Key West, FL 33040
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen (Key Largo) – Famous for their Conch Chowder, a quintessential Keys delicacy. 99336 Overseas HWY
Hogfish Bar & Grill (Stock Island) – Must-try the Hogfish Sandwich, a favorite among locals.6810 Front St, Stock Island, FL 33040
Sunset Grille & Raw Bar (Marathon) – Don’t miss out on their fresh Raw Oyster Platters. 7 Knights Key Blvd, Marathon, FL 33050
Lazy Days (Islamorada) – Their signature Fish Preparations, served fresh from their "you hook it, we cook it" menu scheme, stand out. 7 Knights Key Blvd, Marathon, FL 33050
Key Largo Conch House (Key Largo) – Seafood fans rave about their Lobster Eggs Benedict. 100211 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
Half Shell Raw Bar (Key West) – Their buttery Stone Crab Claws are legendary. 231 Margaret St, Key West, FL 33040
The Waterfront Brewery (Key West) – The highlight is their Brewmaster Burger paired with craft beer. 201 William St, Key West, FL 33040
Island Fish Company (Marathon) – Try their top-rated Mahi Tacos with pineapple salsa. 12648 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050
Islamorada Fish Company (Islamorada) – Beloved for their richly seasoned Fried Grouper Cheeks.81532 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Jannette De Llanos Photography
10 Florida Keys Restaurants for International Cuisine
El Siboney (Key West) – Authentic Cuban dishes like Ropa Vieja served in a warm, lively atmosphere. 900 Catherine St, Key West, FL 33040
Morada Bay Beach Cafe (Islamorada) – Island-style French Caribbean cuisine paired with dreamy beachfront views.
Katch Grill & Beer (Key Largo) – Continental fusion dishes infused with Floridian and Asian flavors.
Alma (Marathon) – Vibrant Latin-inspired meals with a modern twist.
Azur (Key West) – Offers Mediterranean delights like seafood risotto and braised lamb shank.
Cafe Solé (Key West) – Perfect for French-inspired meals in a quaint, romantic setting.
Habana Cafe Republic (Key Largo) – Known for its rich Cuban coffee and refined Havana-inspired menu.
Jakarta Foods (Islamorada) – For lovers of Indonesian cuisine, this hidden spot serves up spicy sambals and satay.
Santiago's Bodega (Key West) – A vibrant Spanish tapas bar with an endless variety of small plates to share.
New China (Key Largo) – Surprising upscale Chinese fusion, with flavors that blend tradition with local seafood.
Jannette De Llanos Photography
Why Dream Bay Resort Is Perfect for Your Destination Wedding
Dining options aren’t the only reason to come to the Florida Keys. Dream Bay Resort is an iconic and romantic wedding venue whose proximity to these world-class restaurants makes it an incredible choice for engaged couples. Here are 10 reasons to choose Dream Bay Resort for your destination wedding:
Exclusive, private property for intimate ceremonies.
Breathtaking ocean views make a perfect backdrop for your big day.
Close to top-rated hotels and restaurants from this list for your rehearsal dinner or after-party!
Unique photography spots, including private beaches and mangroves.
Customizable spaces for small or large weddings.
On-site accommodations for bridal parties and families.
Sustainable venue practices, showcasing eco-conscious initiatives.
Access to local vendors offering catering, florals, and rentals.
A friendly planning team ready to make your day unforgettable.
Proximity to adventurous excursions, including boat tours, snorkeling, and sunset cruises.
Plan Your Next Culinary Adventure in the Florida Keys!
Whether you're planning a wedding, visiting for a romantic getaway, or simply indulging your inner foodie, the Florida Keys offer a dynamic dining landscape that caters to every taste. From luxurious restaurants and locally famous dishes to diverse international flavors, the region's culinary experiences are unmatched.
Add these top restaurants to your list, and don’t forget to check out Dream Bay Resort as a prime destination for your wedding or event. Make your Florida Keys adventure as memorable as the flavors you’ll discover!
Hungry yet? Drop your favorites in the comments below or share your go-to Florida Keys restaurant!
If you're ready to turn your big day into an unforgettable celebration, contact Dream Bay Resort and explore our elopement, micro wedding and full-weekend private packages today. Stunning sunsets, exclusive accommodation, and personal touches await to make your destination wedding a story worth telling. If you’re ready to start planning your Dream Bay Resort beach wedding, we would love to connect with you! From exchanging vows on the water’s edge to exploring the wonders of Key Largo, your destination wedding will be unforgettable when you choose our Florida Keys Resort wedding venue
We would love to invite you and your fiancé to visit Dream Bay Resort for a wedding venue tour or call us for pricing and availability. We host big beautiful weddings, elopements, intimate weddings, micro weddings, weekday weddings and full resort buyouts for the ultimate private wedding experience. For more wedding inspiration find us on Facebook & Instagram. Happy planning, and here’s to a lifetime of love and happiness! Happy planning! 🌴💍
Fill out our contact form to request more information.
As you plan your wedding, we’d love for you to consider a locally owned venue like ours! Check out this wedding venue map to discover amazing locally owned venues across the country. And a big shout out to all the incredible locally owned wedding venues out there!
Somos Family Weddings & Events Tour Amelia Grove Contact Sage View Ranch, 22 Acres Farm book-a-tour Cold Spring Farm Visit Rough & Ready Contact Estate at River Run Wedding Irish Hills Wedding Barn Contact